Some of the links below are affiliate links, which means I will earn a commission at no additional cost to you, if you click through and make a purchase. Regardless, I only link to products we use on our homestead or believe in.
This old-fashioned molasses cookie recipe is the perfect holiday cookie, especially if you’re after down-home simple recipes that Great-Grandma would have baked. You can almost hear the harness and bells jingling as you pull these from the oven.
They have just the right amount of spice paired perfectly with the molasses. I’ve used all different kinds of molasses with these cookies and the ones in the picture are made with blackstrap molasses with a mixture of fresh ground spelt and all-purpose flour. Blackstrap molasses do give them a stronger flavor and generally make them crisper rather than soft, but either blackstrap molasses cookies or regular molasses, they’re delicious!
And who doesn’t need a versatile recipe that can swing either way with both types of molasses?
If you’re looking for molasses cookies without shortening you’ve found them! As I said, these are an old-fashioned cookie and I hate to break it to you, but shortening is NOT an old-fashioned ingredient. Plus, they taste better with real butter, trust me, throw away the shortening for good, you don’t need it.
First, see the tip below on the flour, but form the cookies into 2-inch size balls and increase baking time by 1 to 2 minutes.
If you bake your first sheet and find yourself asking why are my molasses cookies flat it’s because you didn’t use enough flour or your butter was too warm. The flavor and texture is developed with chill time. Seriously, the longer your dough chills the more the spices and flavors come together.
But chill time also can help with cookies spreading flat if you got your butter a tad too warm when creaming it together with the other ingredients. This is true with almost any cookie (chocolate chip) but especially with molasses cookies. To fix it, add 2 to 4 Tablespoons flour (if you’ve only baked 1 dozen, go with 4 Tablespoons, if you baked close to the 1/2 dough, then just add 2 Tablespoons flour), mix until just incorporated, and chill for another 15 minutes.
Yes, bake the cookies, allow to cool completely, and then place on a parchment or butcher paper-lined cookie sheet and flash freeze for an hour. Transfer frozen cookies to a sealed freezer container or a plastic bag. To thaw, transfer frozen cookies to a different container (to avoid condensation as it thaws), thaw and serve!
Can you make the blackstrap molasses cookie recipe dough ahead of time
Yes, you can make this dough ahead of time and store it in the fridge for up to 5 days, make sure it’s wrapped tight so it doesn’t dry out. Or, store cookie dough in the freezer for up to 3 months.
I’ve also heard these cookies referred to as molasses crinkle cookies because they crinkle up on top as they bake in the oven. But no matter what you call them, you’ll find them a favorite and probably a mainstay all year-round, not just during the holidays.
Melissa K. Norris inspires people's faith and pioneer roots with her books, podcast, and blog. Melissa lives with her husband and two children in their own little house in the big woods in the foothills of the North Cascade Mountains. When she's not wrangling chickens and cattle, you can find her stuffing Mason jars with homegrown food and playing with flour and sugar in the kitchen.